Stop The Presses — Again! Scott Burgess Quits — Again!

Jack Baruth
by Jack Baruth

Looks like it’s time for some more Scott Burgess news! Mr. Burgess, whose very existence had long been unknown outside a select circle of hotel room-service supervisors and parakeets who had acquired literacy due to a ruthlessly effective program of eugenics at Petland stores, briefly made Internet headlines last year when he went crazy on a Chrysler 200, quit his paper, was rehired, and fell back into line — not to mention obscurity.

Turns out you can’t keep a good man down. Having briefly tasted the Internet fruit, Scott’s decided to take a job at the salad bar.

According to Bill Shea’s “For Immediate Release…” column in Crain’s Business News… Wait. Do we have time to make a joke about somebody? Of course we do. This is the column header for the “For Immediate Release…” column:

After seeing this graphic, I’m thinking the best candidates for “immediate release” are the children trapped in Bill Shea’s basement. Just kidding, big guy, I read you every week. Back to the story. In his article, which is titled “Detroit New Auto Coverage Team Decimated After Critic Scott Burgess Quits For Job Elsewhere”, Mr Shea notes that the Roman centurion in charge of the Detroit News decided to slay every tenth member of the department to punish them for permitting Burgess to depart without resistance. No, wait. That’s a different meaning of the word “decimate”, one which Mr. Shea calls “archaic” in his response to a commenter on the article. It turns out that “archaic”, like “decimate”, has been given a new meaning by Shea, and that meaning is “a word, the meaning of which eludes me at the moment.” Back to the decimation. Shea actually writes that

Longtime Detroit News auto critic Scott Burgess — he of the infamous Chrysler 200 review incident — is quitting the newspaper at the end of the month for a job at AOL Autos.

“I’m leaving because I think it’s a great opportunity to do more things with AOL Autos, working out of their office in Birmingham,” he told me via email. “I’ll still be writing about cars and the auto industry, contributing to both AOL Autos and Autoblog as a senior editor. For me professionally, it’s a chance to reach a much larger and broader audience.”

This marriage of journosaurs and online media has been tried before, with miserable results (cf. Brock Yates here at TTAC, a variety of people at “Motive”). If there is a place for the buffet-browsers to land online, however, it’s Autoblog. We wish Mr. B the best and look forward to more hard-hitting coverage. The Detroit News, on the other hand, is in a real pickle:

…the paper wants some sort of sharing deal for his AOL content, or something like that, but I don’t know that to be true. It certainly sounds plausible and cheaper. And veteran professional auto critics aren’t exactly readily available.

Uh huh, in the sense that used condoms aren’t readily available in the trash cans of the metro Detroit Motel 6. Seriously, you would think Shea didn’t live in a city with homeless shelters.

In the event that Scott, like Jeff Glucker and Matt Davis, arrives at AOL Autos on a day on which they are not giving the Ethics Lecture, I’d like to offer some suggestions on behavior.

Autobloggers may:

Autobloggers may not:

Got it? Then take, these broken wings, and learn to fly again, Scott! Learn to live so free!

Jack Baruth
Jack Baruth

More by Jack Baruth

Comments
Join the conversation
2 of 37 comments
  • Mullholland Mullholland on Feb 14, 2012

    Jack you never fail to entertain. Not that anyone cares, but I rented a Chrysler 200 this last weekend for $17 per day/unlimited miles. The car had 379 miles on it. I Picked it up Friday evening in L.A. drove it about 1,300 miles to Brian Head UT via Las Vegas to do some snowboarding/play some poker. And you know what: that car wasn't half bad. Cruised at 80, returned 28 mpg on the highway. The seats were comfy, Sirius radio rocked, it even effortlessly handled 6 inches of snow. Even with 50 MPH winds on the drive back the thing was stable and quiet at speed. Maybe Scott was too tough on the 200.

  • Ingolstadt Ingolstadt on Feb 15, 2012

    For those of you who said Jack's personal insults are annoying or too harsh, you guys really need to dig the archives and search for Jack's first attack on Scott, where Jack clearly does his research (and his crazy memory of who/wrote/what/where) on Scott's earlier review of the universally hated Chrysler Sebring and coming out concluding the Sebring with words that wouldn't quite fall out of place for a new E-Class. Yet, after a full 3-4 years, with the rebirth of the greatly improved Chrysler 200, Scott criticizes certain aspects which he used to say was really good in the Sebring, to be absurd unacceptable in the 200. It is this inconsistency of Scott's both articles that made Jack decide that this Burger guy is one big helluva clown doing PR stunts and marketing himself around as the divine autojournogod.

  • MaintenanceCosts The crossover is now just "the car," part 261.
  • SCE to AUX I'm shocked, but the numbers tell the story.
  • SCE to AUX "If those numbers don’t bother you"Not to mention the depreciation. But it's a sweet ride.
  • Shipwright Great news for those down south. But will it remove internal heat to the outside / reduce solar heat during cold winter months making it harder to keep the interior warm.
  • Analoggrotto Hyundai is the greatest automotive innovator of the modern era, you can take my word for it.
Next