By on January 20, 2012

Usually, carmakers officially claim that the worldwide ranking is not important at all. Unofficially, number one is of course preferred to also-ran, and some number cosmetics are par for the course. Remember the catfight between BMW and Mercedes? One company however admits openly what others are trying to hide: For years, Volkswagen wanted to be number one by 2018. It seems that VW is tired of waiting. According to media reports, Volkswagen claims the No. 1 title for 2011. Let’s investigate.

Yesterday, GM announced global sales numbers of 9,025,942. GM did so by hiding a table like an Easter egg in the bottom of a Chevrolet sales report. This announcement took industry watchers by surprise. Usually, GM publishes global sales data in its quarterly report. The Q4 and year end report of GM is due some time in February.

GM`s Global Sales 2011

 GM 2011

Units 2011 Units 2010 % Change
North America 2,924,140 2,625,411 11.4%
Europe 1,735,335 1,662,963 4.4%
South America 1,064,631 1,024,960 3.9%
International Ops 3,301,836 3,072,150 7.5%
Total Global 9,025,942 8,385,484 7.6%

2011 Global Sales Main Volkswagen Brands (Millions)

2011 2010 Change
Volkswagen Passenger Cars 5.09 4.50 13.10%
Audi 1.30 1.09 19.25%
ŠKODA 0.88 0.76 15.30%
SEAT 0.35 0.34 3.10%
Volkswagen Commercial 0.53 0.44 21.40%

Alerted by the New York Times, which did read the Chevrolet report all the way to the end, and which promptly bestowed the title  “world’s largest automaker in 2011” on GM, the rest of the media joined the crowning ceremony.

GM is a reluctant king. Contacts inside of GM confirm that the company never claimed the top spot, and that the new GM wants to forget all boasting with sales records. Easy for them to say. While Toyota was number one, the party line at Koraku 1-Chome 4-18, Bunkyo-Ku, Tokyo, was: “We don’t want to be number one in the world. We want to be number one with our customers.”  The “yeah, sure” now goes to the RenCen, where GM spokesman Jim Cain says “Our goal is to be the best, not necessarily the biggest.”

Today, Volkswagen, not a friend of coquettish talk, was heard. A Volkswagen spokesman criticized vis-a-vis the Wall Street Journal that “Volkswagen’s figures don’t include the contributions of majority-ownership stakes in truck makers MAN SE and Scania AB, which will be added in a few weeks.”

The WSJ promptly turned that into “shortly after GM’s disclosure, Volkswagen argued it, in fact, was the top-seller last year if sales of its affiliates are included.” The WSJ thinks that “the truck makers might add 200,000 vehicles to VW’s sales total.”

Smelling blood, or at least another catfight, that report was promptly picked up by everybody from Motor Trend to Automobile Magazine, which, without using mental math or calculator, said that Volkswagen could be first. Where do they teach that kind of new math?

If you add 200,000 trucks made by MAN and Scania to Volkswagen’s 8.16 million total, then you get 8.36 million. Where I went to school, it was drummed into me that this is some 670,000 less than the 9.03 million reported by GM, and hence not enough for the title. That niggling fact is glossed over in the news reports.

The annoying part is that Automotive News [sub], which really should know better, also says that “Volkswagen Group believes it should be No. 1.” The industry rag faithfully prints that GM sold 9.03 million, that “Volkswagen sold 8.16 million” and that, this one sounds familiar, ”the truckmakers might add 200,000 vehicles to VW’s sales total.” Not one single time does AN raise a hand and says: “Wait a minute.”

Occasionally, one can feel that the writers are getting a bit uncomfortable with a story that does not compute. But nobody speaks up. Instead of saying that 8.36 million are not good enough, old standby Wuling is being trotted out. Wuling sales of over 1 million, AN complains meekly, “are excluded from GM’s total by some analysts because GM doesn’t have a controlling stake in its partner.”

They can exclude that all day long, but it does not matter more than any other analysts guesses.

Nowhere does it say that an automaker must have a controlling interest to recognize sales numbers. Hyundai for instance reports together with Kia, despite the fact that Hyundai has fewer shares in Kia than when they were counted separate. GM currently has no “controlling stake” in any of its joint ventures in China. Will those anonymous analysts take away the 2,547,171 units GM reports as sold in China in 2011?  The counting of Wulings may make people uncomfortable, but GM has a contract that allows the recognition of 100 percent of all of the Wuling sales.

As they clearly don’t teach car counting in J-school, the members of the media are referred to our car counting 101 course, which we had republished again in November in observance of Bloomberg’s premature crowning of Volkswagen as number one.

Capsule version: The sales king won’t be crowned by the media. The king will be declared by OICA, the umbrella organization of the automotive industry. OICA bases its list on numbers reported by the manufacturers. If Volkswagen reports 8.36 million, then this is what the number will be. If GM  reports more than 9 million, then it will be more.

The alleged “auto-industry dust-up over how to count affiliate sales” reported by the WSJ is an invention of mathematically challenged journalists. If Volkswagen complains that someone forgot to count Scania and MAN, it is directed at mathematically challenged journalists.

They didn’t even notice.

Get the latest TTAC e-Newsletter!

7 Comments on “Auto Industry Catfight! GM Number One? Volkswagen Number One?...”


  • avatar
    gslippy

    Maybe we need the equivalent of voter ID laws to govern how vehicle sales are counted.

  • avatar
    alluster

    Awesome Post!!! In the grand scheme of things, being the largest automaker does not really matter. What matters is profitability, profit margins, reputation and customer satisfaction. However, in GM’s case it is really important. People outside the auto industry and non auto enthusiasts have no idea how well GM has been doing for the last 2 years. Most people think of GM as dead or struggling. All my co-workers have no clue that Toyota is not the number 1 car company in the US. What happened yesterday was great for GM in several ways. All the major news papers ran with the story of how GM has toppled Toyota and regained the top spot and how they were building great products resonating well with customers across the Globe and how they were having massive profits (More than $8 Billion) and so on. This news was on every major news site, also very popular evening news shows like ABC world news, NBC Nightly news, Evening news etc and everyone had good things to say about GM’s comeback. That’s free advertising to 24 million viewers just between those three shows. This should change perceptions for a lot of people who do not follow the auto industry, the kind of people who buy the most cars and make them wanna consider GM for their next purchase.

    This should be a motivator for GM’s blue and white collar workers, who worked their butt’s off to make this possible against a sea of constant criticism. They fact they sold more than 9 million units, a mere 2.5 years after standing in bankruptcy court is nothing short of amazing.

  • avatar
    EquipmentJunkie

    Stupid VW. What would happen if Sergio Marchionne decided he was going to add the tractors built by CNH and the trucks built by Iveco in order to bully Fiat’s way up the sales ladder? Or, what if BMW and Honda decided to add motorcycles to their totals? I’m sure that there would be tears in Wolfsburg.

  • avatar
    APaGttH

    And damn it, our tilt steering wheels still go klunk when you use them. Why is this? Why is Hyundai better! Stooges, all of you!!!

  • avatar
    JCraig

    Someone should mention that Honda has yet to report their lawn and garden sales.

  • avatar
    boltar

    Just underscores the fact that, with today’s Balkanized multinational corporations, “biggest” is meaningless.

  • avatar
    doctor olds

    Arithmetic skills do seem weak among too many journalists!
    I note that VW generated nearly 27% of their global sales in China, about the sames as GM’s 28%.
    Both carmakers, along with all the other foreign brands, must do business in China in joint venture with Chinese companies.


Back to TopLeave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Subscribe without commenting

Recent Comments

New Car Research

Get a Free Dealer Quote

Staff

  • Authors

  • Brendan McAleer, Canada
  • Marcelo De Vasconcellos, Brazil
  • Matthias Gasnier, Australia
  • Tycho de Feyter, China
  • W. Christian 'Mental' Ward, Abu Dhabi
  • Mark Stevenson, Canada
  • Faisal Ali Khan, India