New or Used: The Wrinkle in the Luxury Cheapskate

Sajeev Mehta and Steve Lang
by Sajeev Mehta and Steve Lang

TK writes:

I have not owned a car for ten years, having lived in cities where I could take public transportation to work. But now I’m being relocated to a large Great Lakes city where I will forced to drive to work about 25 miles each way. Despite my lack of car ownership, I love cars and I love motoring. Heck, I learned to read by subscribing to Car and Driver. However I don’t like spending vast amounts of money and the thought of burning capital on service costs really galls me.

The other wrinkle here is that I’m an up-and-coming young executive in my company, so it is probably a good idea to have a car that doesn’t scream ”schlub”.

I’ve been thinking about getting a gently used (2008 or so) BMW 5-series, but then I looked at its reliability history and I coughed up a lung. Other competitors: Lexuses seem like a snooze; Infinitis have bizarre interiors with lots of buttons; Audis have dreadful service records; Benzes are for old men.

Any suggestions you might have are welcome. Maybe I need to open my mind to Lexus and Infiniti. Maybe I need to suck up the BMW service costs and accept them in a zen-like fashion. Maybe I need to swallow my ego and get a Hyundai. Either way, please do share ideas!

Sajeev Answers:

Seriously? There ain’t no such thing as a luxury car for the cheapskate, hence the exclusiveness of the term. Except when considering the Lincoln Town Car, which normal people shall not. And considering the flack I get for Panther Love, your average corporate “schlub” won’t schlep in a car so fantastically star-crossed. You my friend, are in a serious pickle.

Consider the Lexus IS: the interior and sheetmetal is right, performance is somewhat inspiring and you don’t look like a rich douche in a BMW or a poseur in a…BMW wannabe machine. And while the IS should fit in the latter category, it really doesn’t. Because, no matter what Pistonheads think, it’s a Lexus…a name that evokes 20+ years of nearly perfect customer service, a bulletproof mid-level manager luxury cache with performance and reliability that’s created a reputation that’s the envy of the world. Whew!

And if you can afford a used IS-F, you get it all in one package. So what was the problem again?

Steve Answers:

This one kinda got me: “The other wrinkle here is that I’m an up-and-coming young executive in my company, so it is probably a good idea to have a car that doesn’t scream ‘schlub’.”

For crying out loud! Who do you work for, Grey Poupon? Nobody is going to give a flying flip about what you drive unless regularly entertain folks with the last names of Trump or Huffington. In which case you definitely better get the stone-aged Lincoln that Sajeev just mentioned.

I am going to give you advice that you are going to hate. Buy a Camcord or a related mid-sized clone. The brand doesn’t matter. Most of them are reliable. Most of them can be had with leather seats. Most of them are virtually indistinguishable for the overwhelming majority of car buyers,

None of my friends ever bought a premium car until they ‘made it’. Even then most of them still never bought a fancy car. If your work requires it. Fine. But my advice is to buy a nice middle-of-the road midsized car that will let you concentrate on your work.

Need help with a car buying conundrum? Email your particulars to sajeev@thetruthaboutcars.com , and let TTAC’s collective wisdom make the decision easier… or possibly much, much harder.

Sajeev Mehta and Steve Lang
Sajeev Mehta and Steve Lang

More by Sajeev Mehta and Steve Lang

Comments
Join the conversation
3 of 122 comments
  • AKRonald AKRonald on Jun 24, 2011

    As a variation on the theme, how about the Lexus RX450h? The hybrid electric system is excellent for crawling along in commuter gridlock but the hybrid system is optimized for performance, rather than Prius economy. AWD is available if desired, and the reliability/back seat comfort is excellent. Another advantage is that if the company culture smiles on having a life rather than 84 hour work weeks, hanging bike rack/ski rack/kayak rack gives the impression that you have wide ranging interests (don't need to own bicycle/skis/kayak). If finances permit, having a convertible coupe (Miata/Mustang) for good weather and an older AWD/FWD for bad might be an option.

    • Accs Accs on Jun 24, 2011

      AKRonald: Luxury isn't a THEME. Lexus sells Luxury like Cadillac is the standard for the world = FALSE. When the underpinnings of the vast majority of what TOYOTA sells through Lexus is a lifted Camry with plastic wood and a system that doesn't give you any actual savings (fuel eco), I don't call that Luxury. P.S, Hyundai is on the phone, they are offering you a loaded Santa FE for as much as.. you want to pay. 1. Explain the point of having a hybrid system on a vehicle with a 3.5ltr 6cycl. Having the weight of a battery on board diminishes any value of having the hybrid system. 2. Any vehicle that has a FRONT BIAS awd unit is pointless, knowing that it doesn't have the TIRES to do the job as designed. 3. Explain the actual benefits in safety in having awd and knowing how to use it and drive it. On top of the few times a year when you THINK you'd actually use the system. 4. EVERY vehicle in its size class, price class, construction category (FAUX Camry wagon for Lexus 5+pass, 40g, unit body) has the same abilities and or construction with roofracks and a awd unit that don't get used. 5. This doesn't stand out. Buying a hybrid for the commuter gridlock doesn't SAVE you ANYTHING. You get RAPED for the price that a "premium" Camry DOESN'T provide, on top of the false benefits of a hybrid. It doesn't improve fuel economy, because the WEIGHT of battery is its own compensation. 6. Ya could buy a Venza / Highlander -- also made on the same frame as the Camry with which it shares motor, transmission, assembly and ALL bones under the plastic wood and overpriced TAG. P.S Ya could go out.. and actually find one of the FEW TRUE Lexus' cars that were actually worth a shit -- the rwd 01 Lexus Sportcross, 3ltr 6cycl motor right from the GS of the same model year. Its a low production car, with great power power to weight balance. Stick on a set of snows and you'd never need AWD. It's got a hatch so ya don't need a RX. Heck, ya could go older and buy a FWD WAGON from any of the japanese (going back 15yrs) and not have any awd / rwd issues.. with a set of tires and the ability to DRIVE THE DAMN CAR.

  • AKRonald AKRonald on Jun 24, 2011

    I was basing my suggestion on my experience with a '08 RAV4 V6 AWD which I drove while living in Montana. On e 2 lane roads I could pass the rear bumper of a farm truck at 60 and the front bumper at 90. Pulled a tent trailer on dirt roads in the summer and handled snowy 2 lane roads in the winter with confidence. Reportedly 0-60 faster than a Miata. Having moved to NM, I no longer drive in the snow or on farm roads so bought a '10 Prius and find it to be excellent. Went to a car show where the Toyota rep explained that the Highlander hybrid was their vehicle with the best pick-up, with the system shared with the RX 450h. Given the desire of the OP to impress his future cow-orkers with his vehicle, I thought the Lexus would be the better choice. I had a friend in college who had bought a very nice MG convertible anticipating her future great job. It didn't come through and she couldn't affort its mechanic bills. Lexus avoids that trap.

  • 1995 SC At least you can still get one. There isn't much for Ford folks to be happy about nowadays, but the existence of the Mustang and the fact that the lessons from back in the 90s when Ford tried to kill it and replace it with the then flavor of the day seem to have been learned (the only lessons they seem to remember) are a win not only for Ford folks but for car people in general. One day my Super Coupe will pop its headgaskets (I know it will...I read it on the Internet). I hope I will still be physically up to dropping the supercharged Terminator Cobra motor into it. in all seriousness, The Mustang is a.win for car guys.
  • Lorenzo Heh. The major powers, military or economic, set up these regulators for the smaller countries - the big guys do what they want, and always have. Are the Chinese that unaware?
  • Lorenzo The original 4-Runner, by its very name, promised something different in the future. What happened?
  • Lorenzo At my age, excitement is dangerous. one thing to note: the older models being displayed are more stylish than their current versions, and the old Subaru Forester looks more utilitarian than the current version. I thought the annual model change was dead.
  • Lorenzo Well, it was never an off-roader, much less a military vehicle, so let the people with too much money play make believe.
Next