By on February 4, 2011

So, what really happened when two of the three hydrogen fuel-cell cars on Mercedes’s F-Cell World Tour ran out of fuel on an early leg? Previously we’d only heard the German perspective on events (not to mention Daimler’s non-telling of the story in the video above), but now TTAC Alum Jonny Lieberman has posted his extended take on the trip over at Motor Trend. Yes, you’ll have to give MT ten page-clicks to read the whole thing, but Lieberman goes into far more detail than any account of the mini PR fiasco yet published. Do give it a look.

Get the latest TTAC e-Newsletter!

10 Comments on “Motor Trend Tells Its Side Of The Mercedes F-Cell Fiasco Story...”

  • avatar
    Educator(of teachers)Dan

    So wait, let me get this straight.  MB brought foreign journalists over to Germany during their 125th birthday party to test drive cutting edge technology and don’t expect them to drive the speedlimit or total lack thereof?  Seriously?  Is it an inability of German engineers to anticipate that their controlled test track calculations might not translate into the real world?  Honestly, guys, Europe is not exactally flat. 

    • 0 avatar

      In defence of Daimler, you can do the “trick”, i.e running out of fuel by driving too fast on any other vehicle as well. From the MT account, the car seems to have a fuel gauge, and they must have known where the rendezvous with the tanker was to take place at. Hmmm…

  • avatar
    Wally Vance

    If you click on the print radio button below the first section, you can read the whole thing on one screen.

  • avatar

    200 kilometers range?  Not much better than an EV.
    BTW, very funny story! :-)

  • avatar

    Speed takes energy.  The mileage at the driven speeds was too low to complete the course.
    The energy density of hydrogen is not good at atmospheric temperature and pressures (hence the high storage pressures).  Where do they obtain the hydrogen?  It’s everywhere attached to other atoms and is expensive to get into pure form (it takes a lot of energy).

    • 0 avatar

      Sounds like they’re reforming the hydrogen from natural gas, at least for this demo. The support trucks (diesel-powered) had several bulk tanks of H2 for roadside “refueling”.
      In a sense, these fuel-cell vehicles are CNG vehicles (as most EVs are coal-powered vehicles).

  • avatar

    Since I rarely read Motor Trend even when I was reading a lot of motor mags, I was a little concerned, but JL did a nice job–sure, no wing-wangs were squeezed, at least that we know of, but entertaining nonetheless, and frankly drunk-driving a 308 and then writing about it is probably something we won’t see again in our lifetime. Oh, wait-you’ve got Baruth working here don’t you.
    I didn’t note much of a discrepancy between the German and American versions of the trip, so there’s no real controversy there. I did enjoy this quote:
    “…as Fred Smith, CEO of FedEx just wrote about petroleum consumption in Fortune, “We cannot continue down this path…”

    Since the FedEx business model is predicated on extensive use of aircraft to provide those overnight deliveries, and there is currently no real plan to replace fossil fuel power in commercial aircraft, I’ll bet he IS worried about an alternative form of propulsion. Anyway, all in all a good read, thanks for the link.

Back to TopLeave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Subscribe without commenting

Recent Comments

  • Re: A Sordid History Of Unicorns

    never_follow - Here’s one local to me I was thinking about checking out a week ago. Sadly I already have 2 cars, only one a unicorn of any description: An Audi V8....
  • Re: Elio Engine Development Proceeds but Trike’s Production Start Pushed Back to 2016

    Zekele Ibo - >> If they hold out until 2016 that is when the Saudis will start running out of money to...
  • Re: Scion’s FR-S Took A Hit In 2014

    Zackman - Just goes to show you that perhaps it’s just not that good of a car, or it has limited appeal – OR the demographic it’s aimed at just...
  • Re: Scion’s FR-S Took A Hit In 2014

    Lie2me - Why can’t you drive a Mercedes to a small town in Indiana, Mr. El Scotto? Last time I checked a Mercedes can be driven there
  • Re: Scion’s FR-S Took A Hit In 2014

    dwford - Let’s face it, there is only so much demand for RWD sports coupes. And there is even less demand for marginally attractive, very small, low power...
  • Re: Scion’s FR-S Took A Hit In 2014

    nickoo - I also doubt it could compete with a 1980s camaro…I would wager on an IROC-Z around a road course over the FRS. ESPECIALLY if the FRS was on stock...
  • Re: Scion’s FR-S Took A Hit In 2014

    Lie2me - Jacob, it was nice of you to compartmentalize us all into nice neat little packages. Old-guy Mustang lovers here, truck lovers over there, but what...
  • Re: Scion’s FR-S Took A Hit In 2014

    Jacob - The affordability of Mustang or front-wheel sport compacts is not a proof that Toyobarus are overpriced. There are millions of Americans who want to own a...
  • Re: Scion’s FR-S Took A Hit In 2014

    kovakp - There’s just not much else to hate today. I mean, who’s ogre enough to really unload on the poor, stillborn Elio?
  • Re: Scion’s FR-S Took A Hit In 2014

    el scotto - Rack up rental points on the company dime; upgrade to Hertz premium on your time. 1st World problems do occur. “Mr. El Scotto you’re eligible...

New Car Research

Get a Free Dealer Quote


  • Contributing Writers

  • Jack Baruth, United States
  • Brendan McAleer, Canada
  • Marcelo De Vasconcellos, Brazil
  • Vojta Dobes, Czech Republic
  • Matthias Gasnier, Australia
  • W. Christian 'Mental' Ward, Abu Dhabi
  • Mark Stevenson, Canada
  • Cameron Aubernon, United States
  • J Emerson, United States