Can You Make 15% Per Year Investing In Classic Cars?

Edward Niedermeyer
by Edward Niedermeyer

IGA Automobile, a new closed-end partnership fund, is planning on investing $150m into “a collection of 20 to 40 trophy marque vehicles with distinguished race or ownership histories” which it claims will appreciate some 15 percent over the next seven years, according to the Detroit News. Though collective buying of super-exotic cars is not new in itself, IGA Automobile fund Director Lancaster claims

This is the first classic-car fund that’s purely for financial returns, rather than passion

The fund, which is advised by Pink Floyd drummer and car nut Nick Mason, has identified several “potential acquisition targets” including the Ferrari 250 GTO, Aston Martin DB4 Zagato, Ford GT40, McLaren F1, Shelby Daytona Coupe and Porsche 917. And, since investors in the fund will be shelling out a minimum of half a million dollars to buy cars that they won’t even be able to keep in their own garage, the investment had better have a chance of making some money. And the fund’s managers think they can make that pitch, as

The Hagerty’s Cars That Matter “Blue Chip” Index, based on the values of the 25 most collectable postwar vehicles, has increased 67 percent from September 2006 to the end of 2010… The Historic Automobile Group International (HAGI) Top 50 index of exceptional classic-car prices was up 6.6 percent in 2010, lower than its average annual growth of more than 12 percent from 2003-08.

That’s better than plenty of investments did over a similar time period… but luxury-goods speculation still has a shaky track record. Besides, doesn’t it seem just a little bit wrong to treat these epic classics like a bond certificate, keeping them stashed away in a vault somewhere? Here’s hoping there’s room in the business plan for some kind of museum.

Edward Niedermeyer
Edward Niedermeyer

More by Edward Niedermeyer

Comments
Join the conversation
3 of 25 comments
  • Chuck Goolsbee Chuck Goolsbee on Jan 27, 2011

    I know somebody who loves cars. Loves to drive them most of all. He's owned several post WW2 classics, from an old MG TD and a Jaguar XK 120, though an R107 Mercedes-Benz. In 2000 he chanced upon a dream car at a good price, a 1957 Mercedes 300sl and bought it. He loved it and drove it often. Last year however he decided he could no longer drive it because it had appreciated in value 450%(!) in nine years. It broke his heart, but he just could not justify the risk of driving a relatively low-tech, drum-braked car on roads surrounded by distracted, innattentive idiots when it was worth so damn much money. That and the fact that all his other investments had lost more than half their value at the same time. So he sold it.

    • Zackman Zackman on Jan 28, 2011

      That's pretty good - I'd have done the same thing. I post this because, ironically, a Chrysler ad on TTAC is advertising PT Cruisers! Didn't they stop building them last summer? I wonder if I bought one now, how much it would be worth ten years from now? It's a nice thought, as I don't have the resources to waste on such speculation anyway. I had an opportunity to buy a 1953 Mercedes 190 back before I bought my avatar in 1970 for $350.00. It was tempting, but I was afraid I wouldn't be able to afford to repair and maintain the thing. As it was, I spent approximately $2200.00 over the course of three years maintaining/repairing/fixing up my Chevy! Oh well, it kept me too broke to get into trouble while I was in the USAF!

  • GS650G GS650G on Jan 28, 2011

    Anyone who ever owned a classic car knows the bottomless pit of finance these cars reside in. Love is what keeps them together. I think I'll keep buying Ford Stock and short GM right now.

  • TheEndlessEnigma Of course they should unionize. US based automotive production component production and auto assembly plants with unionized memberships produce the highest quality products in the automotive sector. Just look at the high quality products produced by GM, Ford and Chrysler!
  • Redapple2 Got cha. No big.
  • Theflyersfan The wheel and tire combo is tragic and the "M Stripe" has to go, but overall, this one is a keeper. Provided the mileage isn't 300,000 and the service records don't read like a horror novel, this could be one of the last (almost) unmodified E34s out there that isn't rotting in a barn. I can see this ad being taken down quickly due to someone taking the chance. Recently had some good finds here. Which means Monday, we'll see a 1999 Honda Civic with falling off body mods from Pep Boys, a rusted fart can, Honda Rot with bad paint, 400,000 miles, and a biohazard interior, all for the unrealistic price of $10,000.
  • Theflyersfan Expect a press report about an expansion of VW's Mexican plant any day now. I'm all for worker's rights to get the best (and fair) wages and benefits possible, but didn't VW, and for that matter many of the Asian and European carmaker plants in the south, already have as good of, if not better wages already? This can drive a wedge in those plants and this might be a case of be careful what you wish for.
  • Jkross22 When I think about products that I buy that are of the highest quality or are of great value, I have no idea if they are made as a whole or in parts by unionized employees. As a customer, that's really all I care about. When I think about services I receive from unionized and non-unionized employees, it varies from C- to F levels of service. Will unionizing make the cars better or worse?
Next