B&B: When You Buy a Car How Do You Conduct Your Test Drives?

David C. Holzman
by David C. Holzman

I’ve test driven new cars during three periods in my life. The first of those periods, the year before I bought the Saturn in ’93, I went out every couple of weeks with a friend to do test drives. The second period was in ’96, when the same friend had me test drive the cars he was interested in while he sat shotgun, telling me that if I didn’t scare him, that would mean the car had passed the handling test. He rejected a Volvo 850 and several others, and bought an Audi A4. Then, in ’00, I helped a friend buy his Boxster, breaking my personal Vmax record on Rt. 128, Boston’s beltway in the process. My testing procedure didn’t call for 115 mph; but the car felt so firmly planted–like the Pentagon!–that I had no idea how fast I was going until I checked the speedo.



I went test driving again in the fall of ’04, under the the mistaken impression that I wanted a MINI. I didn’t. Way too much NVH—reminded me of my Saturn, and the “go-kart handling” just was underwhelming. I was impressed by the 3-series, and subsequently, even more so by the ‘03 Boxster. But I rejected the salesman’s offer in the low 30s. He called me back, inviting me in to deal, and I probably would have gone, except that the next day the election went to Bush, and I became too depressed to part with substantial money.

A week later, one of Steve Lang’s counterparts here in the Boston area—recommended by a friend—called me up, asking me if I wanted a 1999 Accord with a stick and 67k for $5,500. (He was very proud of himself for having found a car with a stick for me.) I got a cashiers check, not knowing whether I’d actually take the thing. But it passed the checklist I had, and when I drove it around the little corner of the parking lot, it was obvious that the engine was far more responsive than the MINI, and far more than either of the Saturn’s engines had ever been. Funny, Robyn, my friend who drove me to pick up the car, wondered why I had demurred at all. Her intuition had quite accurately pegged Greg Stuart as an absolutely honest, good guy. And besides, my research had shown that the car was worth north of 8 Gs. And now, at 181k, the car is still wonderfully responsive.

My modus operandi for test driving new cars is to push them. I make hard right turns off of main drags without slowing down. Repeatedly. I make hard U turns. I get going on the highway at 60-65 and jerk the car into the next lane, and then back. Brakes? EEEErrrrp! Etc. B&B: how do you conduct your car-buying test drives, and have you any good stories to tell?

David C. Holzman
David C. Holzman

I'm a freelance journalist covering science, medicine, and automobiles.

More by David C. Holzman

Comments
Join the conversation
2 of 60 comments
  • Nick Nick on Nov 10, 2010

    My speakers are out...what the hell happened with that Veyron. I don't see any damage.

  • Denvertsxer Denvertsxer on Nov 10, 2010

    Well, I was once conducted unceremoniously off the lot after I conducted a test-drive of the then-new Mk V Jetta. Apparently I was "driving way too fast around that corner."

  • 2manyvettes Since all of my cars have V8 gas engines (with one exception, a V6) guess what my opinion is about a cheap EV. And there is even a Tesla supercharger all of a mile from my house.
  • Cla65691460 April 24 (Reuters) - A made-in-China electric vehicle will hit U.S. dealers this summer offering power and efficiency similar to the Tesla Model Y, the world's best-selling EV, but for about $8,000 less.
  • FreedMike It certainly wouldn't hurt. But let's think about the demographic here. We're talking people with less money to spend, so it follows that many of them won't have a dedicated place to charge up. Lots of them may be urban dwellers. That means they'll be depending on the current charging infrastructure, which is improving, but isn't "there" yet. So...what would help EVs more, in my opinion, is improved charging options. We also have to think about the 900-pound gorilla in the room, namely: how do automakers make this category more profitable? The answer is clear: you go after margin, which means more expensive vehicles. So...maybe cheaper EVs aren't all that necessary in the short term.
  • RHD The analyses above are on the nose.It's a hell of a good car, but the mileage is reaching the point where things that should have worn out a long time ago, and didn't, will, such as the alternator, starter, exhaust system, PS pump, and so on. The interiors tend to be the first thing to show wear, other than the tires, of course. The price is too high for a car that probably has less than a hundred thousand miles left in it without major repairs. A complete inspection is warranted, of course, and then a lower offer based on what it needs. Ten grand for any 18-year-old car is a pretty good chunk of change. It would be a very enjoyable, ride, though.
  • Fred I would get the Acura RDX, to replace my Honda HR-V. Both it and the CRV seats are uncomfortable on longer trips.
Next