MINI Loses Its Tiny Mind, Challenges Porsche 911

Edward Niedermeyer
by Edward Niedermeyer

What?: A race between a MINI Cooper S and a Porsche 911.

Where?: Facebook, and presumably an extremely twisty track.

Why?: Brand equity. Publicity. Mid-life crisis sales. Making sure nobody knows the Cayman exists.


Edward Niedermeyer
Edward Niedermeyer

More by Edward Niedermeyer

Comments
Join the conversation
2 of 29 comments
  • Harold Ray Combs Harold Ray Combs on Jun 10, 2010

    @MarcKyle64: AutoX'd a MINI Cooper regionally for 3 seasons (2003->2005) nearly every weekend. Drivetrain was pretty-much bulletproof, though the old iron-block 1.6L didn't like to rev much. I also don't buy a MINI beating a 911. Maybe if you put Mark Chiles in the MINI and me in the Porsche.

  • DamonK DamonK on Jun 16, 2010

    I think you guys are all looking at the challenge one way, mostly. Many of you are doing an immediate comparison about the mechanical capabilities of each vehicle and immediately picking the winner. Most people who can't afford a Porsche, but could aspire to buy a Mini (I could, for example), only know Porsche through its reputation as a no-nonsense sports car maker (excluding the truck for a moment). Setting up a classic "David vs. Goliath" scenario would help raise Mini's profile in the consumer marketplace by showing some of the Mini's capabilities that wouldn't be immediately obvious to your average consumer. Ford recently compared its Fiesta against a Lamborghini in a commercial recently in a potentially similar, interesting way. If anything, the "how???" hook will draw the public in. Stay tuned.

  • Varezhka Maybe the volume was not big enough to really matter anyways, but losing a “passenger car” for a mostly “light truck” line-up should help Subaru with their CAFE numbers too.
  • Varezhka For this category my car of choice would be the CX-50. But between the two cars listed I’d select the RAV4 over CR-V. I’ve always preferred NA over small turbos and for hybrids THS’ longer history shows in its refinement.
  • AZFelix I would suggest a variation on the 'fcuk, marry, kill' game using 'track, buy, lease' with three similar automotive selections.
  • Formula m For the gas versions I like the Honda CRV. Haven’t driven the hybrids yet.
  • SCE to AUX All that lift makes for an easy rollover of your $70k truck.
Next