By on March 11, 2008

11biofuel02_6502.jpgThe New York Times reports that biodiesel producers are dumping vegetable oil byproducts into local streams and rivers, harming wildlife.The National Biodiesel Board claims that their members' industrial byproducts are "nontoxic, biodegradable and suitable for sensitive environments." Yes, well, Bruce P. Hollebone, researcher with Environment Canada, says the result is some bad shit for birds and fish. "As with most organic materials, oil and glycerin deplete the oxygen content of water very quickly, and that will suffocate fish and other organisms. And for birds, a vegetable oil spill is just as deadly as a crude oil spill.”  The problem is, of course, money. "Glycerin, an alcohol that is normally nontoxic, can be sold for secondary uses, but it must be cleaned first, a process that is expensive and complicated. Expanded production of biodiesel has flooded the market with excess glycerin, making it less cost-effective to clean and sell." And more cost effective to dump in untreated form. The National Biodiesel Board dismissed a litany of violations as "growing pains" for an industry that's doubled in the last year (to 160 plants). Oh, that's OK then.

Get the latest TTAC e-Newsletter!

7 Comments on “Biodiesel Production Producing Pollution...”


  • avatar
    quasimondo

    I wonder what Willie Nelson would say about this.

  • avatar
    NICKNICK

    why don’t we just burn glycerin for fuel?
    should be able to heat a house with it or something.

  • avatar
    Steven Lang

    Well, you could sell an awful lot of candles with glycerin (and a few other cheap ingredients).

    But anyhow, I just recently decided to sell an old Toyota Paseo for my daily commuting and use a 1998 Jetta Diesel. The Jetta cost about $2000 more ($2750 vs. $650), but Atlanta is surprisingly diesel and biodiesel friendly for an east coast city and the opportunity to pick up my first non-Benz diesel (87 350SDL, 95 E300, 96 E300) was simply too great.

    I will use biodiesel, but chances are it won’t be straight bio (about 25%). There’s a distribution center only a mile away from one of my sales and I’ll most likely have a sample evaluated before putting it in my tank. I’ll have to be stocking up on fuel filters as well.

  • avatar
    Landcrusher

    I now see how biodiesel and ethanol can solve our domestic energy problems.

    As all the byproducts of the process to create the fuels creates an ever growing plume at the mouth of the Mississippi and other rivers, the state of NIMBY Florida will relent and choose off shore oil wells over brown water.

  • avatar

    I’m a homebrewer of BioDiesel so I’m aware of the process and dealing with the byproducts.

    Glycerin is not vegetable oil, nor is it an alcohol. I suspect the “Glycerin an alcohol” above should have been “Glycerin AND alcohol” (emphasis mine) since those two things (along with food waste if the source is used fryer oil) are the byproducts of BioDiesel production. Glycerin is basically free fatty acids from veggie oil, bonded to the base element (either lye or potassium hydroxide.) The elements used in BioDiesel reaction are rather toxic in their original form, methanol and the strong base catalysts, but once combined chemically with the veggie oil feedstock to make Glycerin they are rather benign in the larger scheme of things. In fact, you could eat them. Your local car wash or dry cleaner is FAR more chemically toxic than a BioDiesel producer.

    However dumping any of this stuff into the water supply is just plain stupid. Especially since there are ways of safely disposing of these items. BioDiesel producers perform methanol recovery to extract as much of the methanol (by far the most expensive element of BioDiesel production) out of the byproduct for re-use. Glycerine can be safely composted.

    But, like any industry, greed and ignorance can make people take shortcuts. Those who do should be prosecuted, and if need be, shut down.

    Overall though, given the choice of living near a petroleum refinery or a BioDiesel plant, I’d pick the latter by a wide margin. Just because a couple of idiots did something stupid doesn’t mean the whole industry is equally bad.

    –chuck
    http://chuck.goolsbee.org

  • avatar
    Engineer

    Glycerin is not vegetable oil, nor is it an alcohol.
    Whoops! Didn’t do so well in chemistry, Chuck, did we? From the wise people at Wikipedia: Also commonly called glycerin or glycerine, it is a sugar alcohol…

    Glycerin is basically free fatty acids from veggie oil…
    OUCH! Here’s the scoop: A lipid (fat for solid at room temperature, oil for liquid at room temperature) consists of three fatty acids bound to glycerol. Refer to Wikipedia for the graphics. When you make biodiesel, you basically replace the glycerol (an alcohol with three -OH groups) with three units of methanol (one -OH per unit). Hence you consume methanol and produce glycerol as a byproduct.

    The best thing to do with waste glyceride (or glycerol) and waste oil, is to dump it in an anaerobic digester where it gets almost fully converted into biogas, which in turn can be converted into green (but not so clean) electricity. See your local wastewater treatment plant for more on that.

  • avatar

    heh… thanks for the education Engineer. I rely on my Chemist friends to straighten me out now and then. ;)

    –chuck


Back to TopLeave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Subscribe without commenting

Recent Comments

  • Re: European Review: Peugeot 208 GTi

    Buckshot - The 208 GTI is from 229 000 SEK in Sweden Cooper S is from 215 000 SEK but in reality the Cooper will be more expensive with all its expensive options.
  • Re: Mitsubishi Motors: And Then There Were…

    notferris - Mike, First of all, I commend you on this in-depth piece. If you would allow, I would like to offer some additional information that you, and...
  • Re: Thank You And Goodbye (Sort Of)

    Stef Schrader - I feel as if I just read a group hug (in a good way). I do, however, need to chase these feelings of warm fuzziness up with some footage of explosions, and...
  • Re: Thank You And Goodbye (Sort Of)

    April - Accountability and Civility? Really? Allowing comments which include slurs and questioning others humanity is usually considered beyond the pale by polite society....
  • Re: Junkyard Find: 1959 DeSoto

    bill mcgee - It is hard to imagine the styling sensation that the 1957 Chrysler products were when they were first introduced . I recall at the time ,and I was possibly only...
  • Re: Report: Nissan Scraps Small Truck Plans, Navara Now On For North America

    DenverMike - @Lou_BC – The Tacoma regular cab is one of the fastest selling trucks on the planet, close behind the Tacoma...
  • Re: Reader Review: 2010 Volkswagen Jetta Sportwagen

    DeadWeight - Mazda isn’t 50% worse than Honda in this regard (maybe 25% worse, though), and while it’s often stated, tires do make a huge...
  • Re: Thank You And Goodbye (Sort Of)

    msquare - I am very happy to see you at Road & Track. I was wondering who would succeed Peter Egan and I think they found the right person. I came to the web (TTAC,...
  • Re: Thank You And Goodbye (Sort Of)

    MBella - Yeah, not cool Jack. Especially since I’ve never heard Ed say anything but good things about you.
  • Re: Reader Review: 2010 Volkswagen Jetta Sportwagen

    DeadWeight - TTAC hates Saab? I always had the impression that at least the B&B gave Saab credit for doing turbocharged petrol engines properly, and...

New Car Research

Get a Free Dealer Quote

Staff

  • Authors

  • Brendan McAleer, Canada
  • Marcelo De Vasconcellos, Brazil
  • Matthias Gasnier, Australia
  • Tycho de Feyter, China
  • W. Christian 'Mental' Ward, Abu Dhabi
  • Mark Stevenson, Canada
  • Faisal Ali Khan, India