By on August 11, 2003

 I'm convinced my local highway on-ramp was designed by the Pawtucket (Rhode Island) Fire Department. Drivers have just 100 yards of tarmac to join the outside lane of a three-lane road that immediately and violently kinks left. The ramp ends on a bridge, so there's no breakdown lane for failed mergers and there's an off-ramp 200 yards ahead. As you'd expect, cars line up like F14 pilots on a carrier deck. It's the perfect Death or Glory test track for the Pontiac Grand Prix GTP with Competition Group Package: the "Comp G".

Pontiac gave me a fighting chance by transversely mounting a supercharged V6 under the bonnet. The 3.8 litre unit may be older than Abba, but it stables 260 horses. Equally helpful, the super six cranks out 280 ft. lbs. of torque at 3200rpms. By all accounts, it should have been sufficient oomph to keep Pawtucket's paramedics in front of their soap operas.

 The instant I mashed the go pedal I realized that a Comp G at full chat handles just like a Ferrari. Not the car; the logo. The one with the rearing stallion. This front-wheel-drive Pontiac simply can't put its power down from a standing start – or anything resembling a standing start. For the first few seconds, I was literally spinning my front wheels. Finally, with the smell of burning rubber wafting through the AC, with the sound of porcine torture ringing in my ears, the Comp G was off and away.

Obviously, I made it. Once the Comp G's front hooves found purchase, once the ironically named StabiliTrak system tamed the torque steer tsunami, the Comp G rocketed forward with welcome determination. It was fast enough to give credence to Pontiac's claim that their car will sprint from zero to sixty in 6.5 seconds, and finish the quarter mile .564 seconds behind a BMW 330i. Whether or not the Comp G is a credible sports saloon, well, that's another matter…

It sure doesn't look like one. In fact, the Comp G's exterior might have been cobbled together by GM's Performance Car Plausibility Testing Team. Their half-hearted designers grafted every sports car cliché known onto a rental car shape. (Tiny) red painted brake calipers, (blobby) rear spoiler, (faux) quad pipes, and side skirts and a chin spoiler that wouldn't stand out on a mountain bike. The Comp G's front end is its only distinctive feature. It resembles nothing so much as a slightly demented Pokemon character.

The interior also fails to advertise or promote the Comp G's sporting intent. Where the nifty little Mazda6 S, superswift VW Golf R32 and other Comp G enemies boast sexy brushed-aluminum dashboards, clever knobs and multi-colored dials, the Comp G has a dark plastic dash, disco era rotary controls and white-on-grey dials. On the positive side, the XM satellite radio provides plenty of distraction, and the Comp G's "heads-up" speed and radio display is exactly the kind of cool feature that gets the Playstation generation's fingers twitching.

Pontiac proudly promotes the fact that twitching fingers can use the Comp G's wheel-mounted Tapshift buttons to "transform its automatic transmission into operating much like a manual". That depends how you define the word "much", as most manual transmissions have more than four gears. Although the Tapshift's a slick shifter, the limited gearing options restrict its utility to changing down a gear for overtaking or "hey watch this" wheel spins – either of which you can do just as easily by simply flooring it.

Even if you baby the throttle, the Comp G is no hoot to drive. Those of you who know about such things will have already clocked the fact that the Comp G's weight transfers rearwards under hard acceleration, resulting in an inevitable and dramatic loss of front end grip and control. It's what the technically-minded call "excessive understeer" and anyone attempting to blast the Comp G around a corner would call "a bad thing". The Comp G may be relatively safe – the front tyres squeal at the onset of an understeer slide – but it wouldn't be my first choice for a high-speed romp down an unfamiliar twisty.

Given the firepower lurking in the engine bay and the average American petrolhead's distaste for anything other than a straight road, even these handling "issues" would be put to one side if the Comp G was cheap. Thirty thousand US dollars says it isn't. Truth to tell, the only good news is that the top-end Grand Prix is a lame duck. Next year, GM will rebadge and sell the Holden Monaro: a rear-wheel-drive, V8-powered, Australian-made, 2+2 sports sedan with an optional manual gearbox. Sources suggest it will cost only slightly more than a loaded Comp G. The Pontiac GTO will go like Hell and handle like a dream. American onrampaphobics' salvation is at hand.

Get the latest TTAC e-Newsletter!

7 Comments on “Pontiac Grand Prix GTP Comp G Review...”


  • avatar
    moto

    Not one of Pontiac’s best efforts. This car was designed in the era when GM seemed to offer only two vehicles: understeering front-heavy 4-door sedan with 4-speed automatic, or understeering font-heavy truck with 4-speed automatic.

    This was one of the former, although you wouldn’t know it looking at the performance numbers.

  • avatar
    VikingSatan

    The other comment makes no sense? Why would a front heavy rear wheel drive car have excessive understeer ? Wouldn’t it make more sense for it to have excessive oversteer?

  • avatar
    moto

    VikingSatan,

    This Grand Prix is FWD. Well over 60% of its static weight is on the front tires. Yes, it excessively understeers, like most American sedans. It’s a decent car for commuting and hauling kids around, but Pontiac keeps trying to market it as a sports sedan. It isn’t.

  • avatar
    ticketmagnet

    I’m not sure how seriously to take this article when the author starts out by describing how bad he is at driving a front-wheel-drive.

    Then he praises the GTO which didn’t exist yet and which shouldn’t really be compared to a 4-door FWD sedan.

    If you have kids or need to drive in the snow, you’re pretty much stuck with a FWD sedan (or far worse – with a minivan). With that as a given, the GTP is a pretty good car.

    BTW, understeer is generally considered safer than oversteer, which is what those RWD sports cars will give you.

  • avatar
    svenson2009

    Ok. Lets get this right. I have an 04 gtp comp G. You say it shouldnt be a sport sedan you are dead wrong. i have bought an underdrive kit and a cold air intake for mine totaling around $480. Thats all i have done and with those minor adjustments i am getting 0-60 in mid 4s. Not only did it make a hugh difference in my 0-60 time it cut whole numbers off my quarter mile. When i purchased the car it was told to run the 1/4 in about 15.3-16.2.
    I am breaking the quarter mile line now in anout 13.8-14.2. The only thing i tell people when i beat them on the street is” Sedan B***H”. It feels great to drive a 4 door and stop mustangs and camaros. The grand prix gtp comp g is by far the the cream of the crop. In may i get about 2,500 back and can wait to see 12.8 on those lights when i fly by, and after i get done doing that. I’m gonna drive off the track and go pick up my kid from daycare.

    • 0 avatar
      CHRONOS

      I agree, my 2005 Comp G Limited edition with the 5.3 V-8 as amazed my with the g-for on take off. It’s a very strong motor and love the gadgets. I don’t care if it black plastic. Most dashes are plastic anyway. My favorite color is black. I put the Black out package on it and love everything about it. The outside body not only looks classy but it looks ready to get gone as well. I have also blown away mustangs and cam arose. I’m not a GM person and was hesitant on buying this car. I have no regrets with this purchase. Now that Ponyiac is discontinued meets 3 things to me. #1 repairs wil cost more for parts and labor. #2 take better care of it then ever. #3 it will increase in value over time. How many old cars or trucks you see on the side of the road wasting away and you know what it could be worth? This cat it a wet dream all the way around……..

  • avatar
    RON S.

    I HAVE A 2004 GTP/COMPETITION ITS A GREAT CAR. EVERYONE LOVES IT! ITS GRAY WITH THE
    COMPETITION MAG WHEELS,(NOT THE SAME IN THIS MAGAZINE, BETTER LOOKING) FACTORY WHEELS, RED BRAKES, TIRES 245′S AN BLACK WINDOW LUVER’S, AN
    COMPETITION RED LOGO ON THE DOOR. NEEDLESS TO SAY
    I KEPT IT WAXED. I THINK YOU ARE WRONG ABOUT THE PONTIAC DESIGN TEAM, IN MY OPINION THEY DECIDED THE OUTSIDE AN INSIDE RIGHT!!!

    RON S.


Back to TopLeave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Subscribe without commenting

Recent Comments

New Car Research

Get a Free Dealer Quote

Staff

  • Authors

  • Brendan McAleer, Canada
  • Marcelo De Vasconcellos, Brazil
  • Matthias Gasnier, Australia
  • J & J Sutherland, Canada
  • Tycho de Feyter, China
  • W. Christian 'Mental' Ward, Abu Dhabi
  • Mark Stevenson, Canada
  • Faisal Ali Khan, India