Mercedes SL55 AMG Review

Robert Farago
by Robert Farago

After a winter's afternoon spent tear-assing around in Poole Harbour, a thoroughly frozen Mrs F. sank into the SL55's heated seats, switched on the massage button and drifted off into the arms of Morpheous. I immediately began the Sleep Test. How fast could I drive without waking my passenger?

Is that the sound of eyebrows arching? Many enthusiasts will insist that the best way to test a 493bhp automobile is to grab it by the scruff of the neck and thrash it to an inch of its life. Please! Have a little respect. The SL55 may be Mercedes' fastest ever production automobile, but it is not a rally-bred Subaru. It's a Benz. It's a big, heavy, luxury car. Tradition dictates that the SL55's driver displays a certain amount of 'decorum'. Progress should be rapid, yet safe and effortless. Hence the Sleep Test.

If I'd been on a motorway, I could have doubled the speed limit without disturbing my passenger. In a straight line, the SL55 is almost as steady at triple digits as it is standing still. With 5.5-litres of 24-valve, supercharged V8 power on tap, and enough torque to tow a pocket battleship, it only takes 10.2 seconds to crest the ton. The wind roar surrounding the folding hardtop could be a bit of a bother, but nothing the car's killer stereo couldn't defeat. Otherwise, all is serene. If you could link the SL55's 'COMMAND' communications system (how German is that?) to the radar-controlled cruise control, I reckon you could phone it in.

But the road from Poole's offshore playground to the hills of Bath is neither straight nor straightforward. It's a rising falling, twisting turning, broken surface, blind spot ridden, lorry filled, two-lane blacktop. Did I mention that it's narrow? Or the speed cameras? Maintaining rapid yet smooth progress on this stretch of tarmac in Mercedes' glamorous uber-roadster is not so easy (Mr. Bond). I soon learned there's one thing you should never, ever do in an SL55, in a bend, at speed: a mid-corner correction.

Although the 'L' in 'SL' stands for 'light', I defy any enthusiast to apply the adjective to a car weighing 1955kgs. To be sure, Mercedes' AMG fettlers have done everything possible to hide the heft. The SL55's steering, air suspension, chassis and rubber all fool you into thinking you're driving a proper lightweight sports car. As soon as you attempt to adjust the car's attitude during hard cornering, you're instantly disabused of the notion. The chassis lurches, the bow ploughs, the tyres scream, the ESP button flashes and you thank God that you're fully air bagged and crumple zoned.

The SL55's electronic driver's aids will save your bacon, but it won't eliminate your startled passenger's ire. 'Slow in, fast out' is not the answer. Floor the SL55 at any speed, and the belt-driven superchargers spool up with a vengeance. Nanny deals with the inevitable tail wagging, while your passenger wonders why a Jumbo jet suddenly landed in her ears. It's a ferocious feeling, a glorious noise, but it's not easy to control. Mid-corner? Forgeddaboutit.

To pass the Sleep Test, to make progress in the traditional, unruffled Mercedes manner, there is but one possible strategy. Gradually accelerate the SL55 down the straights, slow down before the corners and then glide around the bends. Call it 'fast cruising'. It requires far more concentration and skill than slinging a Porsche Carrera about. (BSM should run a fleet of SL55's.) You mission, should you decide to accept it, is to avoid fully engaging the superchargers.

What's the point of that? Drivers favouring a posh bit of kit and a comfortable cruise would be better off in a cheaper, normally aspirated SL500. OK, the SL55 looks like a proper bloke's car – especially compared to the feminine design of the 'basic' machine. The lower chassis, meaner bodywork and huge tyres project an air of menace at any speed. And the V8 can be provoked into a wonderful, old-fashioned burble with a low-speed prod of the gas pedal. The SL55's interior adds nothing special to the experience, but there are plenty of non-sporting drivers who know the pose value of those AMG badges.

Even so, regular visits to SL Superchargerland are the car's only justification. Never heard of it? That's the new part of Benz World, where well heeled, middle-aged hooligans hoon about in mighty Mercs like TVR-driving twenty-somethings. What it's got to do with the rest of the park, where automotive Muzak plays twenty four seven, I have no idea.

Is the SL55's over-weight flamboyance a welcome break from Mercedes' traditional brand values? That depends on you. If you like pace with grace, no. If the devil owns your soul, yes. In that case, just tell tired passengers to 'sleep when you're dead', switch off the ESP, and hope your words don't prove prophetic.

Robert Farago
Robert Farago

More by Robert Farago

Comments
Join the conversation
  • ToolGuy I do like the fuel economy of a 6-cylinder engine. 😉
  • Carson D I'd go with the RAV4. It will last forever, and someone will pay you for it if you ever lose your survival instincts.
  • THX1136 A less expensive EV would make it more attractive. For the record, I've never purchased a brand new vehicle as I have never been able to afford anything but used. I think the same would apply to an EV. I also tend to keep a vehicle way longer than most folks do - 10+ years. If there was a more affordable one right now then other things come to bear. There are currently no chargers in my immediate area (town of 16K). I don't know if I can afford to install the necessary electrical service to put one in my car port right now either. Other than all that, I would want to buy what I like from a cosmetic standpoint. That would be a Charger EV which, right now, doesn't exist and I couldn't afford anyway. I would not buy an EV just to be buying an EV. Nothing against them either. Most of my constraints are purely financial being 71 with a disabled wife and on a fixed income.
  • ToolGuy Two more thoughts, ok three:a) Will this affordable EV have expressive C/D pillars, detailing on the rocker panels and many many things happening around the headlamps? Asking for a friend.b) Will this affordable EV have interior soft touch plastics and materials lifted directly from a European luxury sedan? Because if it does not, the automotive journalists are going to mention it and that will definitely spoil my purchase decision.c) Whatever the nominal range is, I need it to be 2 miles more, otherwise no deal. (+2 rule is iterative)
  • Zerofoo No.My wife has worked from home for a decade and I have worked from home post-covid. My commute is a drive back and forth to the airport a few times a year. My every-day predictable commute has gone away and so has my need for a charge at home commuter car.During my most recent trip I rented a PHEV. Avis didn't bother to charge it, and my newly renovated hotel does not have chargers on the property. I'm not sure why rental fleet buyers buy plug-in vehicles.Charging infrastructure is a chicken and egg problem that will not be solved any time soon.
Next